The Mortgage Lock-In Effect Continues to Shape Housing Supply — and Quietly Supports Home Values
Why so few homeowners are selling, and what it means for buyers and sellers in coastal San Diego
With nearly 80% of U.S. mortgages carrying rates below 6%, homeowners aren't selling — and that supply constraint is quietly sustaining home values. Advisory San Diego breaks down what this means for coastal San Diego buyers and sellers.
There is a structural force operating beneath the surface of the housing market right now — one that defies the assumption that higher mortgage rates should cool prices proportionally. Approximately 50% of all outstanding U.S. mortgages carry rates of 4% or lower. Nearly 80% carry rates below 6%. Those numbers tell a story about individual financial decisions that, in aggregate, are quietly reshaping the supply side of real estate in ways that will persist long after rates begin to shift.
Economists call this the mortgage lock-in effect. The mechanics are straightforward: a homeowner holding a 3.25% mortgage who sells must, in most cases, finance their next purchase at a rate somewhere north of 6.5% or 7%. On a meaningful loan amount, that difference translates into hundreds of dollars more per month — for the same home value. The rational response, for many homeowners, is simply not to move. Not because they don't want to. Because the financial case for staying is too strong to dismiss.
This creates a supply constraint that operates independently of buyer demand. And that distinction matters. In previous rate-increase cycles, rising borrowing costs dampened both sides of the market roughly in parallel — fewer buyers and more hesitant sellers reached a kind of equilibrium, and prices adjusted accordingly. The current cycle is different in character. The rate differential between existing mortgages and new originations is historically wide, which means the disincentive to sell is historically strong. Sellers are not just cautious. They are locked in, in a very literal financial sense.
The paradox this creates is that the same conditions suppressing buyer demand are also suppressing the inventory that buyers would need to act on. In markets where available homes are already scarce, even a reduced pool of qualified, motivated buyers can absorb what little comes to market quickly. The result: prices hold, and in some cases continue to rise, despite conditions that a simpler rate-based model would forecast as deflationary. Resilience in home values is not accidental. It is the logical consequence of severe supply restriction.
Coastal San Diego makes this dynamic particularly pronounced. Del Mar, La Jolla, Rancho Santa Fe, Encinitas — these are submarkets defined by constrained geography, limited new construction, and deep ownership tenure. Many homeowners here acquired properties years ago at rates that look remarkable by any current standard. The financial incentive to hold is not just present — it is compelling. When a seller does choose to list in these communities, they are entering a market where competition from other sellers is unusually thin, and where the buyer pool, though selective, is real.
For sellers, the lock-in effect reframes the conversation around timing. The common logic — wait for rates to drop, then sell — carries an underappreciated risk. If rates fall meaningfully, the sellers who have been waiting will enter the market simultaneously, and the supply advantage that currently benefits those who list will erode. A seller who moves while inventory remains constrained is working with a structural tailwind that may not persist once the broader market reactivates. The decision to sell is never purely financial, but the financial calculus right now rewards those willing to move while others hesitate.
For buyers, the supply constraint carries a different implication. The expectation of a price correction — one driven by higher rates alone — has not materialized in the markets where it was most anticipated, and the lock-in effect explains much of why. Waiting for distress in markets where listings are scarce and ownership tenure is long is a strategy built on a premise the data does not support. When inventory does appear in a constrained coastal market, the window is often short. Recognizing that scarcity is itself a market condition, not a temporary anomaly, is essential to making well-timed decisions.
The broader picture is one of structural equilibrium rather than stagnation. The housing market is not frozen — it is operating under a specific set of constraints that distinguish this cycle from those that came before. Prices have remained more resilient than many forecast not because demand is unusually strong, but because the supply response that typically accompanies rising rates has been blunted by the financial reality facing current homeowners. That reality — roughly 80% of outstanding mortgages below 6% — is not changing quickly. Its influence on the market will be felt well into whatever rate environment follows this one.
The U.S. Economy Continues to Demonstrate Remarkable Resilience Through a Decade of Disruption
Despite pandemic shocks, energy price spikes, and trade uncertainty, the U.S. has maintained globally enviable growth — a foundation that supports long-term confidence in real assets.
The U.S. economy has absorbed a decade of disruption without breaking. Advisory San Diego explores what that resilience means for long-term confidence in coastal San Diego real estate.
Read the story ›Stay informed.
The weekly market update and new listing alerts, delivered to your inbox.




